William Walter
1781–1783
William Cock
1783–1784
Robert R. Livingston
1784–1800
Jacob Morton
1801–1805
De Witt Clinton
1806–1819
Daniel D. Tompkins
1820–1821
Joseph Enos
1822–1824
Stephen Van Rensselaer
1825–1829
Morgan Lewis
1830–1843
Alexander H. Robertson
1844–1845
John D. Willard
1846–1849
William H. Milnor
1850
Henry S. Atwood*
1850
*(Grand Master of St. John’s Grand Lodge, made Past Grand Master at the Union, December 27, 1850)
Oscar Coles
1851
Nelson Randall
1852
Reuben H. Walworth
1853
Joseph D. Evans
1854–1855
John L. Lewis Jr.
1856–1859
John W. Simons
1860
Finlay M. King
1861
John J. Crane
1862
Clinton F. Paige
1863–1864
Robert D. Holmes
1865–1866
Stephen H. Johnson
1867
James Gibson
1868–1869
John H. Anthon
1870–1871
Christopher G. Fox
1872–1873
Ellwood E. Thorne
1874–1875
James W. Husted
1876
Joseph J. Couch
1877
Edmund L. Judson
1878
Charles Roome
1879
Jesse B. Anthony
1880
Horace S. Taylor
1881
Benjamin Flagler
1882
J. Edward Simmons
1883
Frank R. Lawrence
1885–1888
William A. Brodie
1884
John W. Voorman
1889–1890
William Sherer
1891
James Ten Eyck
1892
Frederick A. Burnham
1893
John Hodge
1894
John Stewart
1895-1896
William A. Sutherland
1897–1898
Wright D. Pownall
1899
Charles W. Mead
1900–1901
Elbert Crandall
1902–1902
Frank H. Robinson
1904–1905
Townsend Scudder
1906–1907
S. Nelson Sawyer
1908–1909
R. Jodson Kenworthy
1910–1911
Charles Smith
1912–1913
George Freifeld
1914–1915
Thomas Penney
1916–1917
William S. Farmer
1918–1919
Robert H. Robinson
1920–1921
Arthur S. Tompkins
1922–1923
William A. Rowan
1924–1925
Harold J. Richardson
1926–1927
John A. Dutton
1928–1929
Charles H. Johnson
1930–1931
Chris C. Mollenhauer
1932–1933
Robert Elliott Owens
1934–1935
Jacob Charles Klinck
1936–1937
Dana B. Hellings
1938–1939
Henry C. Turner
1940–1941
William Frederick Strang
1942–1943
Charles W. Froessel
1944–1945
Gay H. Brown
1946–1947
Frank M. Totton
1948–1949
Ward B. Arbury
1952–1953
Richard A. Rowlands
1950–1951
Carl W. Peterson
1960–1961
Raymond C. Ellis
1954–1955
Nathan Turk
1956–1957
H. Lloyd Jones
1958–1959
Harry Ostrov
1962–1963
Clarence J. Henry
1964–1965
Frank C. Staples
1966–1967
Charles F. Gosnell
1968–1969
William R. Knapp
1970–1971
Lloyd S. Cochran
1972–1973
Arthur Markewich
1974–1975
Albert W. Schneider
1976–1977
William R. Punt
1978–1979
Bruce Widger
1980–1981
Ernest Leonardi
1982–1983
Calvin G. Bond
1984–1985
Robert C. Singer
1986–1987
Roswell T. Swits
1988–1989
Richard P. Thomas
1990–1991
Sheldon K. Blank
1992
Gary A. Henningsen
1993–1994
“Live the Brotherhood! Love the Brotherhood! Share the Brotherhood! And Spread the Brotherhood!“
Earle J. Hino Jr.
1995–1997
Stewart C. McCloud
1998–1999
Carl J. Smith
2000–2001
“Masons = Help“
Carl J. Fitje
2002–2003
“Prayer, Patriotism and Brotherhood“
Edward R. Trosin
2004–2005
“Brotherhood, Philanthropy and Community Service“
Edward G. Gilbert
2008–2009
“Back to Basics“ & “Lead from the Heart“
Vincent Libone
2010–2011
“Faith Integrity & Trust”
James E. Sullivan
2012–2013
“Brotherly Love, Relief & Truth”
William J. Thomas
2014–2015
“Together Everyone Achieves More”
Jeffrey M. Williamson
2016–2017
“Masonry: A Way of Life”
William Sardone
2018–2021
“Building the Future & Masonry Never Stops”
Richard Kessler
2021-2024
“Masons Make a Difference”
Steven Adam Rubin
2024-2026
“It's Called Brotherhood”